Tuesday, March 6, 2007

writer's comments

What kind of intro are you using? Why?

I’m setting the scene, just like the intro in the story.


What do you like best about your paper right now? Why?


I like the way I’m going step-by-step describing the story and commenting on various passages.






What would you work on if you had more time? Why? Try and be specific and please, no comments about grammar.

I would try to input more personal comments and do a better analysis of each section. I would like to relate a character in the story (narrator, Roderick Usher, or Madeline) to Poe himself, but I think there might be a little Poe in each character.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Reader’s Response 1

1.What kind of intro is the author using? Suggest a way to use another effective one.

The intro sets the scene much like Poe does in his stories. It is a vivid description. I would suggest keeping it, and maybe expanding it.


2.Where is the author describing a scene from one of the stories? Suggest at least one other scene from a story the author could use.

Scenes are described throughout the essay using direct quotes from the story. I like how quotes are used rather than the author describing the scene herself. The quotes give the reader the same effect they would get if they would read the story instead of the paper.


3.List any paragraphs where you were confused or unclear about the author‘s intention or meaning. What made it unclear? How could it be said more coherently?

There were no paragraphs that I thought were unclear. JoAnne'sthoughts were well developed, but could be expanded.


4.Suggest one area for the author to revise? How? Try and be specific and please, no comments about grammar.

In the paper, "the acuteness of the senses" is mentioned. This is a reoccuring image in Poe's work and I would try to tie it into the paper to build an argument for madness/insanity in the story.