Saturday, March 10, 2007

my paper

click here to read it: http://www.alexjmacdonald.com/upload/paper1-chekhov.doc

Tuesday, March 6, 2007

Writer's (hey, that's me!) Response

OH GOD sorry I posted this so late, I am terrible with punctuality


  1. What kind of intro are you using? Why?

I put down the topic of the paper (class/gender relating to love in Chekhov’s Russia) and emphasize the class/gender stratification in relation to universal humanity. The literature is a reflection of the times, and I namedrop the Bolshevik Revolution / tragic Russian history in general. If the reader doesn't find that interesting, well, I don't want that person to read my paper.

If I have to pigeonhole it, I suppose it would fall under the “vivid description”category.


  1. What do you like best about your paper right now? Why?

Because Chekhov himself is so economical with words, it was easy for me to extract a large amount of ideas and construct a very solid train of thought in my paper. That makes me feel a warm, tingly sensation somewhere above my intestines but a little below my lungs – the most difficult part of writing papers, for me, is developing my topic into something substantial enough to prattle on about for between X and Y pages.

  1. What would you work on if you had more time? Why? Try and be specific and please, no comments about grammar.

I’d just like to read more Chekhov in general and extend the length of the paper. I’m always a little depressed when I write papers on literature because I can never treat the works in any wholeness – only after being introduced to it for a month and a half at the most, and I can’t really place them in the context of the author’s body of work. While there’s nothing I’d do directly to the paper itself, I do think that it would benefit if I had more time to let my brain marinate inside the texts for longer. One word answer: "more".

writer's comments

What kind of intro are you using? Why?

I’m setting the scene, just like the intro in the story.


What do you like best about your paper right now? Why?


I like the way I’m going step-by-step describing the story and commenting on various passages.






What would you work on if you had more time? Why? Try and be specific and please, no comments about grammar.

I would try to input more personal comments and do a better analysis of each section. I would like to relate a character in the story (narrator, Roderick Usher, or Madeline) to Poe himself, but I think there might be a little Poe in each character.

Writer's Response #1

Writer’s Response #1

What kind of intro are you using? Why?

Right now, my introduction is a quote from Chekhov. I know quotes are lame and overused as introductions, so my intention is to take the quote and elaborate upon it to make it part of an anecdote. Anecdotes tend to be more captivating as introductions and will make my paper more intriguing.



What do you like best about your paper right now? Why?

Right now, I like how I have used many examples from one story. I think it shows that I have a clear understanding of the story and it’s implications about love, happiness, class, and gender in Russia. However, I know I have neglected to cover other stories as much and plan on going back and focusing on the other stories more.


What would you work on if you had more time? Why? Try and be specific and please, no comments about grammar.

I would [and plan to] spend more time on incorporating other stories into my essay. I felt as if one story could be used to cover all of my thoughts, but only choosing that one story limits the themes that Chekhov wrote about. I know that by including examples from his other stories I will strengthen my paper. I also feel that we have read an abundance of Chekhov stories, and to not use the majority of them in my paper would be a waste.

Saturday, March 3, 2007

Long overdue blog re: Nick Adams

Although Nick's lifestyle has some unique, distinctive aspects not common to the average American's (associating with Native Americans, watching his dad perform surgery and seeing the suicided father, etc.), Nick seems like an American everyman to me. This, I think, is due more to the events the stories portray, and their succession -- Nick growing up and learning how to "be a man" -- than the character of Nick himself. Additionally, he doesn't have any traits that cannot be broadly applied to most people. He's a very typical person, which is not to say that he is necessarily uninteresting, but that he is rather average.

The same goes for his father. In each story featuring Nick's dad, he shows a different aspect of fatherhood. Or, rather, the childhood perception of fatherhood; they illustrate the way that fathers are constructed in the minds of their sons. In Indian Camp, Nick's dad is stoic and mechanical. In the one with the logs (the book is on the other side of the room and I am too cozy to fetch it and look up the title) his dad is brash and ill tempered. Nick's dad is a portrait of the father, with all of the oppositional traits that go along with it. (Granted, anybody is a portrait of oppositional traits, but I think that the most common concept of the American father epitomizes them.)

Wednesday, February 21, 2007

Nick Adams

I think Nick is a nice kid. But, poor Nick! He has seen his share of traumatic events (the birth, the suicide)! To make matters worse, his father had to tell him about Marjorie--not very nice. I don't think he's like his father (heartless, egotistical, hot-headed), at least I hope not. Truthfully, I have no idea what those short writings were all about. Maybe I missed the point!

Nick Adams

Nick Adams is the average boy. He learns new things with everything he experiences. Hemingway writes about him in a way that most people can relate to. He goes through relationships, friendships and situations that most people experience as they mature. I don't think Nick is like his father, mainly because he has yet to mature. His father has a respectable career whereas Nick is still a boy. Nick easily loses interest in things [i.e. the birth at the Indian camp] where as his father remains focused. I think as he matures he may become more like his father. The vignettes to me were mainly pointless. Some of them slightly related to the atmosphere of the following story, but I was bored by them and tended to skim them and get to the story.

Friday, February 16, 2007

Gooseberries II: The Son of Gooseberries

Ivan's retelling of his brother's story seems, to me, to be a cathartic act for him. The way that Ivan swims in the lake, exclaiming "delicious!" implies that he is ecstatic at the prospect of getting this burdensome story off his shoulders.

This (if I'm correct in my interpretation) excitement is manifested in Ivan's tendency to get off topic during the story and emphasize the less relevant details. I think it's interesting how Chekhov develops Ivan by using him as a puppet narrator -- Poe also did this to an extent, but Poe's narrators weren't as participatory as Chekhov's.

Wednesday, February 14, 2007

Gooseberries

Gooseberries is a story of an obsession of a dream, gluttony, and social injustice (poor vs. rich). The narrator in Gooseberries, as well as the narrators in About Love and The Man in the Case includes some of the same characters in all three stories, and they tell stories about other people. They create characters that you can visualize in your mind-either you like them or hate them, or sympathize with them or not. The narrators have a tendency to ask many questions without providing the reader answers. Each story has a moral, but interpretation might vary from reader to reader. You can tell that the stories are written in earlier times and many of the words and actions are not of this country, i.e., three men in a tub? Well, not the crowd of people I hang with! In Gooseberries, Ivan Ivanich feels that love and happiness has passed him by. Wishing he was young again, he feels compelled to tell his friend Aliokhin that he should seek happiness--he is still young.

I don't believe the listeners (Aliokhin and Bourkin) learn anything from the story. They are bored and would rather had been told a more interesting story. The only one who seems excited and learned anything about the story is the story teller, Ivan Ivanich. Ivanich learned that you can strive to make a dream come true, even obsess a little, but when you reach your goals, you need to stop stressing and enjoy life because it is too short. I learned that money does not buy happiness (maybe gooseberries). Nikolai ended up alone, with his wealth, a red-haired dog, and a cook.

Saturday, February 10, 2007

Poe POV notes

The narrator of Oblong and Usher tells the story through a very human first person -- his nature, his observations, and his curiosities change throughout both stories. For example, in Oblong, his initial impressions of the box arouse suspicion in him, and he leads himself to believe that his friend is smuggling a painting. This idea is created by the narrator; it is not really implied otherwise. That the narrators have their own personalities and [mis]conceptions changes the presentation of the story to heighten the atmospheric mystery of both works.

Wednesday, February 7, 2007

Point of View

In The Oblong Box, Poe uses first person narrator. He starts out the story using "I" and then halfway through the story, when the storm hits, he starts using "we." In the Fall of the House of Usher, the "friend" is the narrator. He acts like an outsider, looking in, perhaps an observer. In the end we are left not knowing much about the "friend"/narrator. However, the narrator tells us a lot about Roderick Usher.